kevan.org

Mini Mao

A cabalistic card game.

Introduction

Mini Mao is a simple but rapidly-complicating card game for two or (ideally) more players, in which the winner of each round is allowed to add a new rule to the game. All such rules are secret, and their effects must be deduced by the other players through observation and experimentation.

Mini Mao is a cut-down version of Mao - it's a great deal friendlier to new players, without losing too much of the mystery, superstition, deduction or paranoia. The basic game idea is very easy to remember, and you can teach someone to play in a couple of minutes. (Concerned Mao veterans should be assured that this page does not give away any of the significant rules of Mao. I'll explain later.)

Setting up

To play Mini Mao, you'll need a deck of cards. Standard poker cards are best, but the game works with anything - a Tarot deck, Magic the Gathering cards, a pile of (varied) business cards, or whatever you feel like using.

Decks with a couple of cards missing or bent are fine. Leave the jokers in or take them out, it doesn't matter.

Basic Rules

To begin; shuffle the deck, and deal five cards to each player. Place the leftover cards face-down in the middle of the table - this is the draw pile.

Select a player to make up the secret rule for the first round. You can choose the person randomly, or go with the first player to think of one. (In a two player game, both players make up a secret rule.) Secret rules take the form of simple restrictions, side-effects or alterations to play. Some examples would be:-

When a secret rule has been invented, everyone picks their hands of cards up. The top card of the draw pile is flipped face-up onto the table, to form the discard pile.

Starting with the player on the rule inventor's left (or with a random player in a two-player game), players take turns one after another, proceeding clockwise, and each turn they may either:-

If a player plays a card which breaks somebody's secret rule, that rule's creator informs them that they have done so, but does not explain the rule. (For a "must shout bang when you play a five" type rule, the player should be informed "failure to shout bang", but that's all.) The offender takes back their illegal play, and draws a penalty card from the draw pile. (If they broke more than one rule at once, they should be told this, but only get one penalty card in total.) This ends their turn.

If a rule has a trigger effect (eg. "after playing a 2, the next player draws 2 cards" or "after playing an ace, move it to the bottom of the discard pile"), the rule creator should wait until the move is confirmed as legal under everyone else's rules, and then step in and apply the effect. (If two triggers clash, process them according to the clockwise order of their creators, from the active player.)

The first player to empty their hand wins the round. The deck is shuffled back together for a new round, and the winner gets to make up a new secret rule. (Note that this new rule operates in addition to the secret rules from all previous rounds - the game gets more and more complicated as it progresses.)

The game continues until it locks up - eventually the secret rules will mesh in an unexpected way meaning that no card can be legally played on top of the discard pile, or that it is clearly impossible for any player to ever empty their hand. At this point, declare the game over.

Good Secret Rules

When inventing a secret rule, keep in mind that they're always harder to guess than you'd expect. Try to keep it simple and fair - an excessively complicated rule ("You can't play an even red card on an odd black one, unless the second-previous card was of the same suit, or the turn number is prime") won't ever be guessed, and you'll slow the game down having to carefully check every play. And a blatantly abusive rule ("The creator of this rule automatically wins every round! And everyone has to give them money!") just means that your friends won't want to play Mini Mao with you again.

It helps a lot if players come up with a piece of jargon to name each of their rules - usually just a verb or a noun to use when the rule is broken or invoked. ("You can't play a three, you're offside!") This is useful for clarifying which particular rule has been broken, when a player has won several rounds and has more than one rule in effect. This acts as a fair brake to stop leading players from getting even further ahead - if I've won my second round and you haven't worked out my first rule, it's now much harder for you to guess either, because you don't know which rule a given play is breaking. Jargon is also useful for keeping the game intact - you might call a Gronk by mistake, and a third player (who's worked out what causes a Gronk) will be able to question that, rather than assuming that a different rule has been broken.

Jargon can also help you remember a rule when policing it, if the word is obscurely connected with its effect. It's also good for impressing or confusing an external audience - an evolving Mao game is largely indistinguishable from a mysterious, elaborate card game.

Example Game

Aleric, Boris and Colin are playing a new game of Mini Mao. It has been decided that Boris will invent the first rule. (And that whenever they speak in bold, it means they're playing a card.)

Boris : [thinks] "Okay, I've got one."

[ Boris flips the top card of the draw pile - it's the three of diamonds - and everyone picks up their hands. ]

Colin : "Right. The eight of hearts."

Aleric : "King of spades."

Boris : "Five of clubs."

Colin : "Two of diamonds."

Boris : "Sorry, that's a Pip, you can't do that."

[ Colin grumbles, takes back the two of diamonds, and draws a penalty card. The top card is 'five of clubs' again, and it's Aleric's go. ]

Aleric : [tentatively playing a card] "Is the two of clubs okay?"

Boris : "Sorry, no."

[ Aleric takes back his card and draws a penalty. ]

Boris : [pleased] "Nine of spades."

Colin : "Three of hearts?"

Boris : [deciding to be generous and give Colin a clue] "No, too low, you're Pipping again."

[ Colin takes back his card and draws a penalty. ]

Aleric : "I think I've got it. Ten of hearts?"

Boris : "That's fine. King of hearts."

Colin : "Eight of hearts...?"

Boris : [silent nod]

Aleric : [triumphant] "Nine of clubs!"

Boris : [despairing at his cards] "Bah. I pass."

Jokers and Aces

If your deck includes any cards which don't comfortably fit the usual criteria of other cards, you can refer to them as jokers (perhaps they are jokers) - they can be played as if they were a copy of any other card from the deck; the player calls a card when they play it.

If you're playing with a poker deck, be sure to agree whether aces are high or low; ideally before the game. You can make their highness or lowness part of the secret rules ("Number cards cannot be played onto higher number cards, and aces are low for the purposes of this rule."), but it can get confusing if two rules treat them differently.

Background

Mini Mao began when I was killing time with some friends and a deck of poker cards in 2002, and, on the subject of games with hidden rules, I vaguely recalled Mao - but only that it was a Bartok variant, with secret rules and no initial ones (not even suit progression). We played a dozen or so games of it like that, starting a new batch of rules whenever we got bored, and it worked.

Checking for "official" Mao rules online when I got back near a computer, though, I found that they were actually quite elaborate - standard Mao can be regarded as an already-begun game of Mini Mao, where the game so far has already been played for a dozen or so rounds by some Californians you don't know. It forces you to play a certain type of game, with suit progression and number-effects, and doesn't seem to encourage "rebooting".

Mini Mao is just a crystallisation of the rule-making, rule-breaking and rule-meshing aspects, putting the first rule-maker only one rung above everyone else, and making the game a lot more personal for those playing it.

And it's a much kinder game to introduce to new people, particularly if you're the only one who's played it before. The world needs more games that you can explain in three minutes and play for hours, with a single deck of any old cards.

Further Reading

Maobot
 Play Mao against a Javascript opponent, in your web browser.

Mao at Wikipedia
 Usually with some rules, unless they've been deleted again.

Bartok Rules
 Bartok is like Mao, but the rules aren't secret - they're declared to everyone when created. This Bartok ruleset also offers some good ideas for secret Mao rules.

Nomic.net
 Nomic is the purest abstract of the self-modifying game - this site offers a lot of good resources, and links to places to play.

Dvorak Poker Deck
 If you want to play Mini Mao online, you can feed this poker deck into the Dvorak MUSH Engine.